Skip to content
Literary Yours
Menu

Best Secret Santa Gifts: 5 Picks That Won't Disappoint

Five Secret Santa gifts that work when you barely know the person: a paperback, good chocolate, a card game, a jigsaw and a hand cream.

Gloved hands holding a red plaid wrapped present

How to buy a Secret Santa gift for someone you barely know

Secret Santa is a strange brief. You are buying for someone you may only know as "the one who prints everything", to a budget somebody else set, and then watching them open it in front of twelve people.

The gifts that survive that moment tend to share the same traits. They are useful or edible. They do not need to know anything about the recipient. And they are obviously not something that has been fished out of a drawer at the last minute.

Everything below is chosen against those rules. Nothing here needs a size, a favourite colour or an intimate knowledge of someone's kitchen — just a decision about how safe or how silly you want to be.

The quick answer

If you only read one thing, read this:

  • You have never spoken to them: buy the book or the hand cream. Both are universally acceptable and need no personal information.
  • Your team has a sense of humour: Exploding Kittens. It gets played, not shelved.
  • You want the group to share it on the day: Tony's Chocolonely. One big bar, opened immediately.
  • They keep saying they can't wait to do nothing over Christmas: the jigsaw.
  • You genuinely know their taste: ignore all of this and buy to it.

The five picks compared

Everything here is size-free and easy to wrap — the differences come down to who will actually use it.
PickWhat it isSuitsThe risk
The Thursday Murder ClubPaperback cosy crime novelAnyone who reads, at any ageA keen reader may already own it
Tony's Chocolonely Milk Chocolate BarLarge bar of milk chocolateShared desks and shared kitchensDairy, and anyone avoiding sugar
Exploding KittensCard game for two to five playersTeams that like a laughNeeds other people to play it
Gibsons 1,000-piece jigsawJigsaw puzzleCosy nights in and quiet JanuarysTakes up a table for a week
L'Occitane Shea Butter Hand CreamHandbag-size hand creamPeople whose hobbies you can't nameScent is personal

Best overall: The Thursday Murder Club

Best overall

The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman

4.5/5

A paperback is the safest "I don't know this person" gift there is, and this is the safest paperback. Richard Osman's cosy crime novel about four residents of a retirement village who meet to discuss unsolved murders is warm, funny and completely unintimidating. It is not gory, it is not literary in a way that puts people off, and it reads quickly — which matters when the gift is opened in front of a group and everyone wants to know what you bought.

It is also the gift most likely to be passed round a family afterwards, which is the closest a Secret Santa present gets to a compliment.

Why it works

  • Appeals across ages, from teenagers to grandparents
  • No sizes, batteries or instructions
  • Easy to wrap badly and no one will mind
  • Can be lent on or passed along after reading

Where it falls down

  • No use to someone who only reads on a phone
  • It is a popular title, so a keen reader may already have it

Best crowd-pleaser: Tony's Chocolonely Milk Chocolate Bar

Best crowd-pleaser

Tony's Chocolonely Milk Chocolate Bar

4.5/5

Chocolate is the most reliable crowd-pleaser in any gift guide, but a supermarket bar looks like exactly what it is. Tony's Chocolonely bars are noticeably chunky, and the segments are deliberately divided unevenly — a design choice meant to make a point about inequality in the cocoa trade — so the bar looks different and starts a conversation before anyone has eaten any.

Milk chocolate is the safe flavour, and a big bar can be opened and shared across a desk on the day, which spares the recipient the awkwardness of pretending to love an ornament.

Why it works

  • Almost universally liked
  • Shareable the moment it is unwrapped
  • The unusual segments make it memorable
  • Easy to find in supermarkets and chocolate shops

Where it falls down

  • Not suitable for a vegan or dairy-free colleague
  • No good for anyone cutting out sugar
  • Chocolate does not enjoy a warm office radiator

Best for a laugh: Exploding Kittens

Best for a laugh

Exploding Kittens

4.3/5

For a team with a sense of humour, a small card game beats another novelty mug because it actually gets used. Exploding Kittens is quick to learn, plays with two to five people, and the artwork is deliberately ridiculous. Rounds are short, so it works over a lunch break or at the Christmas do without anyone having to commit to a three-hour board game.

It is also small enough to live in a bag or a desk drawer, which is exactly what you want from a gift you did not choose yourself.

Why it works

  • Rules learned in a few minutes
  • Works with a small group, not just a dedicated gaming crowd
  • Small box that fits in a work bag
  • Gets played, rather than stored

Where it falls down

  • The daft humour will not suit everyone
  • Needs at least one other willing player
  • A poor fit for someone who genuinely dislikes games

Best cosy pick: Gibsons 1,000-piece jigsaw

Best cosy night in

Gibsons 1,000-piece jigsaw

4.2/5

A jigsaw is the gift for the person who has announced, loudly, that they intend to do nothing at all over the Christmas break. Gibsons is a long-standing British puzzle brand with sturdy pieces and a wide range of scenes, from nostalgic village views to modern illustrated designs, so you can match the picture to the person rather than guess at their taste in much else.

A thousand pieces is a proper few-evenings project: something to do with the radio on, or with a visitor who needs occupying. It is also one of the few gifts here that gets used more than once.

Why it works

  • A screen-free activity for the dead week between Christmas and New Year
  • Large range of designs to suit different tastes
  • Sturdy enough to be done again or passed on
  • Good for couples, families or a quiet solo evening

Where it falls down

  • Needs a table left out for several days
  • A thousand pieces is a real commitment
  • Some of the traditional scenes skew older than others

Best small luxury: L'Occitane Shea Butter Hand Cream

Best small luxury

L'Occitane Shea Butter Hand Cream

4.4/5

A really good hand cream is the classic "small but not thoughtless" present. L'Occitane's shea butter version is the one people recognise, and it comes in a handbag-sized tube as well as larger sizes, so it fits inside most Secret Santa limits without looking like a token.

It is genuinely useful in a British winter, it needs no size or shade, and it works for someone whose hobbies you could not name under interrogation. Pair it with a decent bar of chocolate if you want it to feel less like a toiletries-basket filler.

Why it works

  • Instantly recognisable and hard to be disappointed by
  • Useful in cold weather and easy to keep in a bag
  • No size, shade or model number needed
  • Feels more considered than a last-minute buy

Where it falls down

  • Fragrance is personal and will not suit everyone
  • Some people deliberately avoid scented products
  • Assumes they use hand cream at all

What matters when you're buying blind

Universal appeal
5.0/5

If you cannot name their hobby, choose something almost everyone eats, reads or uses.

No sizing or specification
5.0/5

Nothing that needs a size, a shade, a model number or a plug type.

Looks like a proper present
4.0/5

Good wrapping and a decent bar of chocolate beat an expensive item chosen at random.

Likelihood of being used
4.0/5

Consumables and games get used. Ornaments get shelved, then quietly moved on.

Fits the agreed limit
4.0/5

The cap is the point of the exercise. Overspending makes the person who picked your name feel awkward.

Two practical checks before you commit. First, is it safe to open in front of a mixed group of colleagues? Anything that comments on someone's appearance, age or drinking habits fails that test. Second, could you give the same gift to any of the other names in the hat without embarrassment? If yes, you have bought well.

Common Secret Santa mistakes

Most Secret Santa disappointments come down to a handful of repeat offenders:

  • Gifts that need information you don't have. Clothing sizes, ring sizes, skin tones, dietary needs.
  • Jokes at the recipient's expense. A gift that gets a laugh from the room but a fixed smile from the person holding it is not a good gift.
  • Alcohol by default. It is a lovely present for the right person and an awkward one for a non-drinker, someone pregnant, or anyone whose relationship with drink you don't know about.
  • Wildly overshooting the limit. It puts everyone else's gift in an unflattering light.

The verdict

Secret Santa questions, answered

What should I spend on a Secret Santa present?

Spend the agreed limit, not more. The cap exists so everyone gives and receives something comparable; going over it makes the whole exchange feel uneven, and going under it is noticed more than people admit.

Is alcohol a good Secret Santa gift?

Only if you know the person drinks. Many workplaces now discourage it, and it is an awkward thing to hand to someone who is pregnant, teetotal or simply not a drinker. A nice bottle of something soft or a good chocolate bar avoids the question entirely.

Is a gift card a lazy Secret Santa present?

It is the safest option and the least memorable one. If you go down that route, choose a card for a shop the person actually uses and add something small and edible so there is still something to unwrap.

How do I label a Secret Santa gift?

Write the recipient's name clearly on a tag, and keep the tag visible after wrapping — a gift that gets separated from its label at the bottom of a bag is a problem nobody wants to solve in front of the group.

Should I buy a joke gift or a proper one?

A good joke gift is also a good present: something funny that the person will genuinely use. A joke at their expense — an insulting mug, a book about ageing — tends to land badly, especially in a work setting.